In January 2011, Kesler Dufrene, a 23-year-old Haitian immigrant with a history of nine arrests, murdered three people in North Miami, Florida, after being released from deportation due to a moratorium following Haiti’s 2010 earthquake. This case, a stark example of immigration policy failures, underscores the deadly consequences of inadequate oversight of criminal aliens. The victims—Ashley Chow, 15, Harlen Peralta, 25, and Israel Rincon, 35—were shot dead in a home, highlighting a preventable tragedy that Bristol Blog examines as part of its focus on criminal justice issues.

Case Details

Kesler Dufrene, who entered the U.S. illegally at age 14, had a criminal record including charges for battery, theft, and drug possession. Scheduled for deportation, he was released in 2010 under President Obama’s moratorium on Haitian deportations post-earthquake, with minimal supervision (monthly check-ins, which he skipped). On January 2, 2011, after relatives reported concerns, North Miami police found Ashley Chow, Harlen Peralta, and Israel Rincon shot dead in a home at 350 NW 132nd Street. Dufrene, who reportedly did not know the victims, was killed by Manatee County deputies on January 19, 2011, during a burglary and shooting in Bradenton, Florida, as reported by the Miami Herald.

Deportation Policy Failures

The 2010 moratorium released 687 Haitian convicts, including Dufrene, under “supervised release” or on their own recognizance, per federal statistics. By January 2011, when the moratorium lifted, only 90 were re-detained and deported, with 16 awaiting deportation. The remaining, nearly 600, remained at large, often without electronic monitoring. Additionally, tens of thousands of Cuban felons, undeportable due to Cuba’s refusal to accept them, were on supervised probation, exacerbating the issue. Critics argue this leniency enabled Dufrene’s crimes, as noted in the Miami Herald.

Immigrant rights groups called deportation efforts “racist,” arguing Haiti’s poverty and cholera crisis couldn’t handle returning convicts, and labeled Dufrene’s case “extremely isolated.” However, the lack of oversight—Dufrene faced no consequences for missing check-ins—reveals systemic flaws in managing criminal aliens, fueling public outrage.

Kesler Dufrene

Victim Impact

The murders devastated the victims’ families, who expressed anger over the halted deportation. Audrey Hansack, mother of 15-year-old Ashley Chow, told the Miami Herald, “This guy shouldn’t have been in America. I’m so upset with the whole situation. Because of immigration, my daughter is not alive.” The families, unaware of any connection to Dufrene, remain frustrated by the unsolved motive and demand accountability for the policy failures that allowed a known criminal to remain free, as reported by the Daily Mail.

Conclusion

The Kesler Dufrene case exposes the tragic consequences of inadequate deportation policies, allowing a repeat offender to murder three innocent people, including a teenager. This Miami tragedy reflects broader criminal justice and immigration challenges, which Bristol Blog documents to advocate for reform. Stricter oversight of criminal aliens could have saved lives. We call for balanced immigration enforcement that prioritizes public safety while addressing humanitarian concerns, urging policymakers to prevent such failures.

References

Share This Article

More violent crime:

Threat of Leftwing Philosophy

Related:

Bristolblog banner.